Delivery agencies don’t come much newer than city development companies. So how are the people who run them getting on? The chief executives of Creative Sheffield and Hull Forward tell Josephine Smit about the plans for their cities

City development companies are the shiny new GTIs in the car fleet of regeneration delivery agencies. With a broader-ranging remit than their immediate predecessors, the urban regeneration companies, they will need experienced drivers to get the best out of them. The first CDCs have exactly that. Some big figures with expertise across both public and private sector gleaned from national and international regeneration are being attracted to take on the role of having a physical impact on a city, and laying the foundations for, they hope, sustainable prosperity.

While some may shudder at the thought of government creating yet another quango, CDCs promise an outcome that the government finds highly attractive in allying economic growth with physical regeneration. There is also the potential for CDCs to reduce quango numbers at a local level, as a number are being created from existing urban regeneration companies (URCs), and can incorporate other agencies, as at Creative Sheffield which incorporates URC Sheffield One, investment agency Sheffield First and the Cultural Industries Quarter Agency.

The government set out its proposals for the CDC concept for English cities and city-regions in the 2006 local government white paper and published a consultation document on their role last December. Already cities are seizing the nettle and embarking on the process of establishing a CDC. Sheffield led the way with Creative Sheffield, which officially came into being in April this year. Others are following suit, like Hull Forward.

Hull Forward

Former deputy prime minister John Prescott may have retired from the regeneration stage, but his former constituency is still in the vanguard of delivering change. Upcoming city development company Hull Forward is set to grow out of the urban regeneration company Hull Citybuild and former director of regeneration at One North East John Holmes last month took on the job of chief executive of Hull Citybuild and chief executive designate of the CDC. Holmes has worked in private and public sectors, including a stint as urban renewal consultant to the then Department of the Environment.

How far has Hull Citybuild brought the city in five years? The URC has focused on five or six developments in the city centre. They are all within a very tight area and are interrelated. Some have taken a while to get off the ground, but there is a feeling that here is a city that is on the cusp of something big. When you add all the initiatives going on here together – the URC activity, Building Schools for the Future and Housing Market Renewal you have a couple of billion pounds of investment in the area.

With good universities, the port and employers like Smith and Nephew it is an increasingly outward facing city.

How much further has the city got to go?

In terms of major developments the 50,000m² St Stephens opened last month. That is the first major scheme completed here. Then Humber Quays is on the way, the Fruit Market is in the process of selecting a developer, we have planning permission for a residential and hotel development and the Quay West mixed-use scheme is in masterplanning.

Are this year’s floods a setback to the aspirations?

There may have to be tweaks on the housing side in the light of them, but the city centre was virtually unaffected. Confidence in the city has not been affected.

What difference will CDC status make to delivery and what will Hull Forward’s priorities be?

CDCs have the flexibility to encompass economic regeneration. We need to make sure the area is sustainable, that graduates stay and that the companies that set up business remain. A priority will be to make sure policies are aligned – the CDC has to reflect the regional economic strategy and the strategies of the Northern Way and Yorkshire Forward. We also need to make sure that private sector players feel a part of it; we have a business forum up and running already.

But how will Hull Forward distinguish Hull from all the other locations trying to attract businesses and people?

We have to be realistic about what’s there and what can be delivered. We’ll have to play on our USPs – for example, we have the port, so there is the potential for port logistics. Then there’s tourism – a million people pass through the passenger terminal. I've had to queue around the corner to get into the aquarium the Deep – it has been an incredible success and the city also has a historic core with a museum on William Wilberforce. There is the potential for cruise tourism.

What are your biggest challenges now?

Our biggest challenge is getting there. I want to hit the ground running. But it will all need careful management between now and next April when the CDC becomes operational.

What made you want to move to Hull, and particularly to a CDC?

Given my background in physical regeneration it was a good opportunity and it was timely that the URC was moving into a CDC. I have worked in Hull before; in the late 1980s I was seconded by the Department of the Environment to work as project manager on Victoria Dock.

What are the most important lessons that working in the private sector has taught you – and from the public sector?

From the private sector, learned resilience in being able to talk the talk with investors. From the public sector, I have learned how systems work, at a national, regional and sub-regional level.

Creative Sheffield

Creative Sheffield is the country’s first city development company, officially fully formed on 1 April of this year.

Canadian Ian Bromley moved from Toronto to become chief executive a year ago. Bromley has a considerable pedigree in management consultancy, economic development and communications and marketing in a career that has taken him to Japan, China, New Zealand, Brazil and the US.

This month he was named vice-chair of the Internationl Economic Development Council.

How far has Sheffield One brought the city in its regeneration?

Sheffield One gave us a city centre that is a heck of a lot better than it was. It has one of the nicest public realms around and a functioning office market with no need for gap funding. It has taught the city how to run an effective partnership. There are things that you can do as a quasi-independent body that you can’t do as a council. It has given confidence that things are improving.

How have you made the shift from URC to CDC?

The city development company was talked about three years ago and I came on board a year ago. The management team has been operating for a year as a unified group.

What comes next?

We have the delivery of the economic masterplan and the business plan which from April of next year will take us from an interim body to a company that is fully funded from fewer income streams. The old companies had lots of different budget streams, but now we will have one unified budget. In the meantime, we have the Sheffield Digital Campus, the retail quarter and elements of the existing masterplan. We are out there all the time dealing with a strong flow of inward investment.

What difference does CDC status make to delivery?

What distinguishes the CDC in my mind are the fact that it has the independence and multi-partnership style of a URC, and the full range of tools to achieve the economic transformation of the city.

There is accountability there is one agency with lead responsibility for economic development of the city, and it is accountable to business, government and city. We have nowhere to hide.
Then there is integrated thinking and delivery. The Digital Campus has been a physical project, but now it is all about achieving what it will be.

What are your biggest challenges now?

Our biggest challenges are to get funding to deliver on the masterplan, and how we put together an economic investment plan for the next five or 10 years. The city’s objective is
to achieve English average economic performance that may not sound much of a target, but pretty much all the core cities are below it.


That would mean producing an extra 30,000 jobs and an increase of £1,500 per person in gross value added – and that is a 15-year target. It is a target we’ll have to push to meet, but it is achievable.


We are also working in an ever changing environment, with the sub-national review, the changing role of English Partnerships. We have to keep our focus on delivery in a time of change.

What made you want to come to Sheffield, and particularly to a CDC?

I had done a lot of international consulting and advisory work and thought it would be good to set down roots. From a career point of view, this is a place where I can make a big difference. Toronto is like London, it is growing at the rate of 100,000 people a year. Sheffield has all the assets for serious success but strategic smart economic development can make a big difference.

North America already has development companies. Is there anything we can learn from there?

There are development companies in North America but none is structured quite the way a CDC is. This is groundbreaking and absolutely the right way to go.

What have you learned from working in the public sector - and from working in the private sector?

Working in both gives you the perspective to understand both sides. Even in the public sector there are quite big differences, between say central government and the local council. The private sector is competitive, focused on the bottom line and has much clearer lines of decision-making.