Are you paying your accountants enough? Kate Freeman reports on rising pay from payroll clerks up to finance directors, and the perks tempting them into the sector
demand for finance directors just keeps on growing and the need to tempt the best candidates into all the financial roles created by stock transfers and arm's-length management organisations, salaries are going up. Some pay packages are now equal with the private sector, which has suffered a slight fall.

According to Hays Accountancy Personnel, which put together the latest annual review of accountants' salaries, the housing sector is taking advantage of this parity and increasingly looking outside its boundaries to hire finance experts.

The average salary for directors of finance at large registered social landlords rose 3.9% on last year to hit £65,533. Although regional variations were huge – £34,000 in Northern Ireland compared with £100,000 in central London – it compares well with the average salary of £73,126 for RSL chief executives, as revealed in our 2004 salary survey (HT 5 March, page 26). The 3.9% increase is above inflation, which is 1.4%, and compares with a 4.1% average pay increase across all RSL staff.

Heather Clarke, business manager for Hays, says: "The housing sector is extremely buoyant because of the increasing diversity of associations created from stock transfers, ALMOs and tenant management organisations. That is creating, particularly at a senior level, a significant shortage of candidates and this is reflected in salary."

In central London, the salary offered to a head of finance at a large association has increased from about £45,000 to £55,000 over the past 12 months, Clarke says.

The problem of high demand is exacerbated by an increasing scarcity of qualified accountants over the past five years. Registered social landlords are now advertising for staff in general accountancy magazines and websites as well as outlets specific to RSLs.

The sector does offer attractive perks, though. Pushpa Raguvaran, deputy chief executive and director of finance at Housing 21 in Buckinghamshire, says housing's shorter working hours and caring ethos are appealing. "At a senior level, people are very choosy about where they work and they are drawn to housing associations by altruistic reasons," she says.

RSLs are also more likely to offer home-working, flexitime and shorter hours – 40 hours a week rather than 60.

Orbit Housing Association in Coventry offers flexitime, private healthcare and is accredited as giving "gold standard" support for employees for employees taking the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants' professional exam. Claire Davis, group finance director at Orbit, says it recruits many junior posts from the private sector: "Quite often, small private practices pay less than us, and our package is quite attractive, so once here, they stay."

Meanwhile, at new RSLs, there is the opportunity for senior staff to mould the finance department the way they want it (see "Why accountants go for the sector", below).

In the private sector, a regional finance director in the Midlands makes £80,000. A housing association finance director gets £82,000 in the West Midlands and £62,500 in the East Midlands. Clarke says: "Salaries are fairly comparable at the top of the scale. Public sector salaries are typically a couple of thousand pounds less than the private sector, but the terms and conditions are better."

In junior positions, pay scales are similar to the private sector: a private payroll clerk gets £15,341, compared to £16,067, £15,650 and £15,174 at large, medium and small housing associations (see "Who gets what", below)

However RSLs do pay their finance experts more than councils. The head of finance in a metropolitan borough council gets an average of £49,942, compared to the £65,533 for a director of finance at a large association. Staff at post-transfer landlords tend to stay on these slightly lower pay scales but they often enjoy final-salary pension schemes and flexitime.

Perhaps the most attractive factor, though, is the fact that housing offers a level of job security unknown in the dog-eat-dog business world. "Redundancies are extremely common in commerce and industry," says Clarke. "But it's extremely rare to have redundancies in the housing sector."

Why accountants go for the housing sector

Andrew Taylor left his job as senior manager at a leading accountancy firm to join Sunderland Housing Group as group finance director. “I was working as lead adviser for the stock transfer of properties from Sunderland City Council to Sunderland Housing Group when I gained an insight into the association’s business potential and decided to apply for the job. “I was looking for the right move outside of practice, but I wondered whether I would find such variety in the not-for-profit sector. Joining Sunderland when it had just been formed offered quite a rare opportunity to set things up, and the three years since transfer have seen a significant transformation. “Sunderland looked like it could be a successful business given the right leadership and direction, because the underlying business was strong. I also joined a great team, that is insightful, innovative and passionate about success. “It was important to me to use skills I’d accumulated in my past career. I thought it was possible to create a lot of value in the sector, and it’s particularly appealing that any profits would benefit tenants rather than shareholders. “I would recommend the sector to anyone from the private sector who’s looking for an exciting and challenging career as a finance director. For the next five years, I don’t see that outlook changing.” Steve Schofield was an qualified accountant for a company in the food industry before joining Whitefriars Housing Group in Coventry as assistant accountant. “Until I looked into what housing associations do and saw the variety of tasks they do, like repairs and keeping properties at an acceptable standard, I just associated them with collecting rent. “My job is basically the same as it was in private industry and I get similar pay. “But the working hours seemed to be a lot better than in private industry, where it’s very competitive and you are frowned on if you don’t do four or five hours extra a week. Here, as long as the work gets done, no one’s making notes and they won’t stare at you when you leave. “Where I worked before, you had to work an extra five hours a week before they paid overtime, and before that, they didn’t pay overtime at all. “But here we work flexitime and if you work extra hours you can book half-days off. The private sector is just about money – they just don’t look after their staff in the same way.”

Related files/tables